Tuesday, December 17, 2019

Major independent YouTube channel banned from posting links on Facebook for trying to post a link very critical of YouTube's performance

Well, I’m aghast at this one.  Ford Fischer  (“News2Share”) was banned for 60 hours from sharing links on his Facebook account for posting a “ReclaimtheNet” article critical of YouTube’s behavior in 2019 (which included demonetizing Ford on the same day it tried to resolve the Maza-Crowder controversy).
So the site wrote an article about banning Ford.   There seems to be a possibility that the article spoke quasi-favorably about someone that Facebook considers "dangerous" or part of the white nationalism (and FB may well believe this incorrectly about a few of these people).  

The earlier article went into great detail about YouTube’s knee-jerk reactions to external pressures all year, culminating in the COPPA settlement with the FTC and then its fuzzy expansion of an anti-harassment policy. 
I tried an experiment and simply posted a link to the site home page on my own Facebook account, and it had no problems.

It is very unusual to ban links (unless they go to porn) – and there is supposed to be an informal “server rule”.
I also had a bizarre exchange over one of my own small YouTube posts, from the QA for the screening of “Freelancers: Mexico”.  I explain this in a Tweet thread. I had a similar incident commenting on a Virtual Legality thread about the anti-harassment policy and COPPA. Please act as if it is wrong to comment on something unless your own skin is in the game and in the line of risk.

No comments: