Thursday, April 29, 2010
NJ middle school principal wants all kids off social networking sites even at home!
Orsini was tripped off by “Formspring” (link) which apparently allows kids to make anonymous comments about one another, somewhat in the spirit of "people rating" sites discussed earlier on this blog (in conjunction with the workplace).
North Jersey offered the article by Leslie Brody and Evonne Coutrous, “Ridgewood principal to parents: Get your kids off Facebook” link here
Orsini admits that the good kids and parents (many individually able to handle the responsibilities of Internet use at home at young ages) are being asked to “sacrifice” for order of everyone. It only takes a few kids to engage in cyberbullying or defamation to create enormous disruption for the entire school, even from computers off campus and at home.
Orsini hinted that gay-bashing and body-image issues were particularly pernicious on the Internet among some younger teens.
ABC Good Morning America interview of Orsini by George Stephanopoulous on Aptil 29.
Jason Kessler has a story on CNN link here, title "Principal to parents: Take kids off Facebook." "There is absolutely no reason for any middle school student to be a part of a social networking site!," he wrote. "Let me repeat that - there is absolutely, positively no reason for any middle school student to be a part of a social networking site! ...It is time for every single member of the [school] Community to take a stand!"
Ironically, the article says, Orsini is a member of Facebook.
Tweens don't have the resilience to stand up to online name calling, he says, which is a much bigger problem than bullying inthe physical world (especially probably for girls).
There is an ethical question: if use of social networking sites doesn't produce a tangible benefit at this age and presents an unbounded risk that can interfere with others' doing their job (finishing school) then it could be banned.
Update: May 2
A cover story on p 5 of the Sunday May 2 Washington Examiner "Region's schools, parents try to rein in bullying" by Leah Fabel and David Sherfinski", reports that in Montgomery County MD at Lakelands Park Middle School, two students were arrrested for making Facebook threats (presumably from home computers) with theFacebook moniker "Ur Worst Enemy".
Update: May 6
The front page of the New York Times today has a story by Tamar Lewin, "Teenage Insults, Scrawled on the Web, not Walls", about anonymous grafitti on Formspring, link here. People can link a Formspring account to a Facebook or Twitter account and invite anonymous comments. Users can ignore anonymous questions, but most tweens seem unaware of this option. Formspring has about 28 million visitors a month.